News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Warrnambool Christian Brother's lengthy history as a sex offender revealed 

Warrnambool Christian Brother's lengthy history as a sex offender revealed

01 Jun, 2011 04:00 AM
THE lifting of a court order has revealed the extent of a former Warrnambool Christian Brother's years of sexual abuse against numerous young victims.

Robert Charles Best, 70, pleaded guilty in the Melbourne County Court on Monday to six offences between 1975 and 1988 which involved three victims.

Best's pleas ended a long legal pursuit for justice by victims, investigators and prosecutors.

His pleas also lift a court ban issued almost a year ago that enables The Standard to report that juries in six separate trials since November have found Best guilty of 21 sex offences against eight victims.

He was acquitted of two charges of sexual penetration and gave evidence in some trials, which were held consecutively and all tenaciously defended.

A complainant died before one trial.

Best's admission of guilt also ended the need for a further five trials.

Charges were found proven by juries, or Best entered guilty pleas, in relation to 11 of 15 complainants.

Police collected statements from complainants between 2002 and 2008.

There was a committal hearing in 2009 and the 11 trials started in November last year.

Best was principal at Ballarat's St Alypius Catholic Primary School between 1969 and 1973.

He taught at the Christian Brothers' College (now part of Emmanuel College) in Warrnambool between 1989 and 1994.

Before his time in Warrnambool, Best had taught in Fremantle and Launceston during the 1960s, East Ballarat 1968-73, St Leo's in Box Hill 1975-85 and St Joseph's College in Geelong from 1985-89.

In July 1996 Best received a nine-month suspended sentence for the sexual abuse of an 11-year-old pupil in 1969.

During 1998 he won a retrial after being jailed on similar charges for two years. The retrial did not go ahead.

Christian Brothers Oceania issued a statement after Best's guilty plea, offering a "sincere and unreserved" apology to the former students sexually abused by him.

Its executive officer for professional standards, Brother Brian Brandon, said the Christian Brothers were "deeply saddened by these events, especially the great distress and suffering caused to these victims and their families".

He added that the Christian Brothers ''view abuse in any form and, particularly, the sexual abuse of the young and the vulnerable as repulsive''.

Best's pleas to six charges, including two of aggravated indecent assault of a boy under 16 will result in the discontinuation of some charges and a permanent stay of others.

Prosecutor Amanda Forrester said Best's pleas "will clear all of the matters in respect of this accused crimes committed between 1969 and 1988".

Defence counsel Sarah Leighfield asked that a date for a plea hearing be set in July to allow reports on Best from an oncologist and a psychologist.

Best, who told court on Monday he was a retired teacher now of Port Phillip Prison, will return to court on July 25.

The south-west has previously been labelled the paedophilia capital of Australia due to the number of former priests and Christian brothers who have been found guilty of sex offences in the region.

In 2006 Paul David Ryan, 64, was sentenced in the Warrnambool Magistrates Court to a minimum 12 months' jail for abusing two boys at Penshurst in 1990.

Gerald Ridsdale, Bryan Desmond Coffey and former Catholic brother Edward Dowlan, who each served in the Warrnambool area, have all been found guilty of sex charges.

In 1994 Ridsdale was sentenced in Warrnambool to 18 years in jail, which was effectively extended by another four years after he was found guilty of another 35 offences in 2006.

athomson@standard.fair fax.com.au

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I was 12, when I went to secondary school. Problems at home, then the big step to maturity. No safety! This is what happened. The brother walked in the room first day/morning. His first words were 'my name is Brother #### and if you tangle with ##### look out!' From that day on he methodically beat two boysmornings severely, outside the room, so we all could hear. Then he would bring them in, white as ghosts. In the afternoon, he was calm and funny, and he chose me! He would stand behind me, and I would feel warm and fuzzy. But in the mornings, my stomach would spazm with anxiety. My tummy broke, anxieties grew, depressions, by 16 I was beginning the life of a drug addict. By 35 I was clean! Wednesdays that year in Grade 7, I still blank out! I cannot recall those terrible Wednesdays. That Brother is old now, he never went to jail, he was too cunning. And the Edmund Rice Foundation still supports him. Some of the Brothers, were great men, infact two are dear friends of mine at local 'soup' kitchens. And love, is the only way! Jesus is not God, a man, with a heart of 'beatitude'! The miracle of faith is not a belief, it is a dynamism, a seed within the profound potential of heart!!!
Posted by shaman, 1/06/2011 7:27:34 AM, on The Warrnambool Standard
This article says Paul David Ryan was convicted for abuse of 2 boys. Much more than this, is what really happened, read the shocking truth here http://brokenrites.alphalink.com.au/nletter/page117-ryan.html Its time for real healing, and a radical change of the religious mindset in our societies, and in the world, and a deepening of collective responsibility. Any ideology, clashing with another, claiming democracies and freedoms as their objective, and using force and SILLY PHALIC shaped weapons, ie, war and violence, and suggesting God's sanction...is simply a FALSEHOOD of the unhealed human heart. The only solution in my opinion is a profound re-spiritualization. Who are we? What are we here for? Where are we going as a global humanity? These questions need to be asked. Earth is like an ovum, in the birthing waters of a galaxy, we have not given collective birth yet. We are in the pangs of it! Please forgive me for the rant again...but we need think bigger than the box now! And think! Lets work within the dynamism of faith, which is infact the gift of humanities heart! Not a dead myth, but a possible new living and powerful universal myth...to discover what we truly are as humans
Posted by shaman, 1/06/2011 7:47:11 AM, on The Warrnambool Standard
May these creeps burn in hell
Posted by jetstar, 1/06/2011 9:26:48 AM, on The Warrnambool Standard
And they wonder why their numbers are falling, lock him in mainstream not isolation cells, let him feel the same terror as his young victims.
Posted by squirm, 1/06/2011 9:26:50 AM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Very sad!!!! Brother Best taught me at Emmanuel College and thought he was great, although he did exhibit some inappropriate behaviours - very subte, but inappropriate. I think this is antother case that proves that ALL people have the right to sexual relationships - it is part of our basic needs in life! To deny priests, nuns, and brothers of this causes this sort of irrepairable damage to innocent victims. WAKE UP CATHOLIC CHURCH - celibacy is not natural!!!!!
Posted by anon, 1/06/2011 10:20:18 AM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Those of us who were at Emmanuel College in 1996 will remember that Principal Peter Richardson used a newsletter to parents to call for support of Brother Best and proclaim his innocence. Many parents were shocked and horrified at this appalling misuse of the school newsletter. These pedophiles and their supporters will bring down the Catholic Church.
Posted by jhc, 1/06/2011 11:56:10 AM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Anon: how can you say that denying a person a sexual relationship leads to pedophilia??? these are two very different things. Someone doesn't become interested in young boys because they can't have a sexual relationship with a member of the opposite sex of the same age!
Posted by em, 1/06/2011 12:06:21 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Priests and Brothers do not become pedophiles because of celibacy - pedophiles become Priests and Brothers because it gives them the opportunity to be a 'trusted' adult left alone with children. I remember him at Emmanuel College in the early 90's. He acted very inappropriately toward students, male and female. jhc: I remember seeing that newsletter, I was shocked also.
Posted by annaboo, 1/06/2011 12:22:26 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Used to walk past that school and often heard kids getting yelled at and thought

glad I dont go there

Posted by gavin couzens, 1/06/2011 12:39:51 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
It's weird that one so trusted can be so depraved. Please don't use this though to tarnish all Christian brothers. Brother Richardson was defending a man he thought he knew well. The man in the dock admitting to these atrocities is not the man he thought he knew, he had a lot of good people tricked. The Christian brothers mission is a good one I'm an athiest and I believe in their basic pathos. The victims have a right to justice and we are right to condem the actions of this one individual. But remember the mask he wore whilst at Emmanuel college was convincing and those who defended him then are feeling sick today.
Posted by Anon, 1/06/2011 1:12:25 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Robert Best, pictured leaving court in 1998.
Robert Best, pictured leaving court in 1998.
Robert Best
Robert Best

Most popular articles




The Warrnambool Standard







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...