News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 CSIRO book's vegetarian advice enrages MP 

CSIRO book's vegetarian advice enrages MP

28 Sep, 2009 04:00 AM
AUSTRALIA'S peak industrial research body is conspiring to force farmers off the land through a new green living book, a south-west MP claims.

Western Victoria Liberal MP John Vogels, has slammed the CSIRO's Home Energy Saving Handbook, which promotes vegetarian diets to reduce agricultural green house gas emissions.

"It seems tofu-munching climate change extremists and animal libbers have taken over the CSIRO, wasting taxpayer funds to publish books designed to wipe out our agriculture industries with the ultimate goal of forcing farmers off the land,'' Mr Vogels said.

"As a nation we need to move beyond the kindergarten view that livestock generate greenhouse gas emissions and focus climate change strategies on reducing those emissions which are genuine pollutants.''

A link on the CSIRO website about the handbook directs people to the Victorian Government's Department of Health webpage which highlights the benefits of introducing children to a vegetarian diet.

It states: "For most well and healthy children a vegetarian diet can provide a healthy and nutritious alternative to a diet including meat.''

Mr Vogels called on the CSIRO to apologise to Australian livestock and dairy farmers for publishing what he believed was a "flawed'' climate change handbook.

He said the organisation had abandoned its 90-year charter to support agriculture industries.

"Former prime ministers Billy Hughes and Stanley Melbourne Bruce would be turning in their graves because they established the CSIRO to assist Australia's primary and secondary industries, not to attack or undermine farmers,'' Mr Vogels said.

"These former prime ministers would never have created the CSIRO if they knew it would one day be used as a vehicle to close down our beef, sheep and wool industries.''

Mr Vogels said taxpayer dollars should be spent on making coal-fired power stations greener by investing more in carbon geosequestration.

The CSIRO said the book was a "guide designed to help Australian households reduce their carbon footprints and take action against climate change''.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
An individuals choice of diet is more important than their choice of car in terms of the detrimental impact of their carbon foot print. Conclusion of the UN report "The long shadow of animal agriculture"
Posted by veganath, 29/09/2009 12:05:44 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Vogels is a joke, eating a steak in protest of the CSIRO and I bet that is coming from our tax payer pocket instead of his. He should the one getting the shack for wasting tax payer money for such a stunt. Get the fact straight about climate change instead of rambling on about CSIRO history. Just goes to show that this joker has absolutely no idea what he is talking about and just wasting tax payer money indulging when he should be doing his job like reading up on climate change issue and listening to top scientists from the UN before openning his mouth.
Posted by Bill of Rockhampton, 29/09/2009 12:11:49 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Dear Mr. Vogels........ No doubt you are aware of my views on climate change. I thoroughly commend your comments on the CSIRO's balderdash, and support you wholeheartedly. I would like to point out to you that the DPI are currently running brainwashing "seminars" on climate change for farmers in our area, and should be roundly criticised for these farcical events. What a waste of taxpayers money! It's time the CSIRO had their funding cut off, as you correctly say, they are now just a haven for obsessive greenies, who seem intent on ruining the economy of our once great country. Sadly, the CSIRO are now hanging on to the global-warming gravy train for dear life, and now no longer do useful science, just science fiction, and fantasy.
Posted by Don Ward, 29/09/2009 12:28:49 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Keep eating that red meat Johnny. It will make you die of something fun like heart disease or colon cancer quicker, then the smart people can get on with saving the planet in peace.
Posted by Jo, 29/09/2009 1:11:03 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Precious bunch these veg-heads!!! Teenage vegetarians are like teenage lesbians, in the end, they all go back to the meat! Plus, I smell a concerted effort to sway the fine city or Warrnambool’s public opinion on behalf of the mung bean set… no one else in the three years that the Standard have had reader comments has anyone bothered to submit a comment
Posted by Plover Bea, 29/09/2009 1:40:01 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
It's a shame that Mr Vogel thinks that supporting the meat industry is more important than supporting the planet. It is scientifically proven that livestock production is the single biggest cause of carbon emissions. It doesn't matter how much money we spent making coal-fired power stations greener, as long as we still slaughter animals for meat our environment will be suffering. Nothing Mr Vogel says can change this fact. The meat industry won't be much good to anyone if we haven't got a planet that can support us! Let's face it: vegetarianism is better for the animals, our bodies and our planet. Make the switch.
Posted by Kimberley, 29/09/2009 2:02:49 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Well done to CSIRO for publishing the Home Energy Saving Handbook. It covers a whole range of ways to cut down on our greenhouse gases, including cutting out or reducing our meat consumption. Mr. Vogels, you obviously need to be better informed. At the New York Climate Summit just recently, our world leaders were warned that they need to take decisive action now because we only have less than a decade before we reaching irreversible climate change. Changing our eating habits is definitely part of the solution. So Mr. Vogels, why not try eating more vegetarian meals and less meat. It certainly won't kill you and you will be doing something positive towards helping the planet.
Posted by Matilda, 29/09/2009 2:57:03 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
How sad Mr Vogels. It would be so nice to have intelligent unbiased and well informed polititians. I wonder, are you going to take up smoking to help save the tobacco farmers? Are you going to drink lots of alcohol to save the brewers? Are you going to drive a bigger car to save the jobs of petrochemical company workers? Carbon sequestration is an unprovan technology that will take years to develope and millions of Dollars. Changing to a vegetarian or vegan diet is a simple, achievable, healthy and a proven way to reduce a person's carbon footprint. Also lets give Australian farmers credit for being intelligent people who have the ability to change with the times and grow alternative food products when demand for dead animals decreases.
Posted by Clive, 29/09/2009 5:38:07 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
Mr Vogels doesn't sound like he cares about the planet!
Posted by Blacky, 29/09/2009 6:56:04 PM, on The Warrnambool Standard
O my, I feel sorry for the MP, for being so ignorant. He should really not say anything, to save himself from further embarrassment. Everyone knows that eating less meat is clearly beneficial to the environment. The Chief of the Noble Peace prize winning UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) even goes around the world giving lectures on the topic of reducing meat consumption and the benefits to the planet. How big of a carbon footprint does meat have? http://www.meatthetruth.nl/conten t/view/117 Here is an organization that conducted a study, created a carbon saving table, and made a documentary film about it. There's tons of environmental orgs that also talk about the impact of the meat industry on climate change. Greenpeace, World Watch, David Suzuki's site mentions it also. Do the research before you open your mouth.
Posted by Laura, 30/09/2009 5:22:53 AM, on The Warrnambool Standard
< previous |  1 | 2 | 3  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
MP John Vogels has a steak in protest against a CSIRO climate-change book urging people to eat less meat. Picture: THE AGE
MP John Vogels has a steak in protest against a CSIRO climate-change book urging people to eat less meat. Picture: THE AGE

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 14%
2) Apple iPhone 4 32GB43 plans 6%
3) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 1%
4) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
5) Samsung Galaxy S15 plans 4%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press

 
Footy Tipping


The Warrnambool Standard







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...